The ex-girlfriend of a Brunswick man accused of killing his mother testified in Medina County Common Pleas Court Tuesday, recalling an argument between the defendant, James Tench, and his mother, Mary Tench.
James Tench, 30, faces charges of aggravated murder, murder, aggravated robbery and evidence tampering in the death of Mary Tench, who was reported missing on Nov. 12, 2013, and who was found dead later the same day in her Ford Escape. If convicted, James Tench could face the death penalty.
Tench was dating Christina Kyker of Euclid at the time of his mother’s disappearance. Kyker, who was called as a witness by the prosecution in the capital murder trial, testified she started dating Tench during the summer of 2013 after meeting him online. She said she often visited Mary and James Tench’s shared Camden Lane home.
During one visit, Mary Tench brought up James Tench’s credit card use while the three were eating breakfast, she said.
“She told me since we’re getting close I should know about this,” Kyker said.
Mary Tench started showing Kyker envelopes with financial information inside, stating James was using her credit cards to buy Kyker gifts such as concert tickets and clothing, Kyker testified.
“As she kept grabbing the envelopes, he grabbed her arm and she froze,” Kyker continued.
Kyker said the grab was sudden and made a slapping noise. Mary Tench looked scared and walked away and James Tench went to his room, she said.
During defense attorney Rhonda Kotnik’s questioning, Kyker said she followed James Tench and talked to him. He soon calmed down and Tench and his mother made up, she said.
“James and Mary hugged and they cried together,” Kotnik said, which Kyker confirmed.
In the days following the discovery of Mary Tench’s body, police found her financial documents in both James’ and her bedrooms, one of the prosecution’s witnesses, Brunswick police Officer Greg Hayest, said.
Hayest said police found a bank statement for Mary Tench’s account between the mattress and box spring of what police believe was James Tench’s room. Police found digital copies of Mary Tench’s checks in the master bedroom, which was believed to be her room, Hayest testified. At least one check was made out to James Tench. Dates, check numbers and dollar amounts written in the margins of a newspaper found in Mary Tench’s closet correspond to the digital copies, Hayest said.
Police also found the words “Leave, tell police” on a Target envelope left on James Tench’s nightstand, Hayest continued.
During a pretrial hearing, county Prosecutor Dean Holman pointed to these items as evidence that James Tench was stealing from his mother and Mary Tench knew about it.
Hayest said he also found several items in a garbage bag inside the house including duct tape packaging, which prosecutors allege is the same brand as the duct tape found around Mary Tench’s neck when her body was discovered.
However, Hayest said he did not see any sign of a struggle inside the house when defense attorney Kerry O’Brien questioned him.
Several of Tench’s co-workers at his former places of employment — the Strongsville and Fairlawn locations of Old Carolina Barbecue — also testified for the prosecution Tuesday.
Tench was convicted in Cuyahoga County Common Pleas Court after pleading guilty to robbing the Strongsville restaurant in October 2013. He was arrested on the robbery charges after police searched the home following the discovery of Mary Tench’s body. James Tench has been serving a five-year sentence in the Richland Correctional Institution since 2014.
Several of his superiors at the barbecue called him a hard worker and recalled Tench talking about his mother. Old Carolina Barbecue franchise director John Casey said Tench told him his mother was dying of cancer, despite reportedly telling Brunswick Officer Christopher Scafidi his mother had no medical issues when he filed a missing persons report.
“He said she had cancer and she was dying, which was one of the reasons he was living at home,” Casey said.
Casey — who was questioned by police about nine months after the discovery of Mary Tench’s body — testified that during the fall Tench started complaining about his mother.
“He said she was driving him crazy and he couldn’t stay there anymore,” Casey said.
Sarah Morgan, an employee at Old Carolina Barbecue, said she reported Tench to management in the fall of 2013 after he told her he hated his mother.
The manager at the time, Juan Parilla, said two employees complained about Tench’s statement. He added the employees also reported that Tench said he wanted to kill his mother, which Morgan denied.
Both Morgan and Parilla were interviewed by police about nine months after the incident, the defense pointed out.
Parilla testified he talked to Tench after the complaint and Tench didn’t deny the report of the other employees.
“He laughed and said, ‘Well, she might as well be,’ ” Parilla said.
“Might as well be dead,” Parilla clarified.
The jury trial continues today before Common Pleas Judge Joyce V. Kimbler.